COGNITIVE ERGONOMICS

Redesigning infusion pumps to reduce unintentional errors.

From this in real life

We observed paediatric ward (PICU) staff set up pumps, noted errors and redesigned

controls to align with their thinking.

Click here to see prototype

to this prototype

METHODS

TEAM

MY ROLE

SETTING

Ria Mehta & Ishaan Choudhary

Field research, DISCO Analysis, Interface Design

Paediatric ICU, Manipal Hospital, Bengaluru

Observation, DISCO Analysis, Interviews & Primary research

The project in 30 seconds

PROBLEM

WHAT WE FOUND

WHAT WE CHANGED

In a paediatric ICU, infusion pumps are used daily. One wrong action can cause harm.

Nurses juggle patients. Errors happen when machines don’t fit their models.

New controls and layouts for both pumps that reduce unintentional errors.

THE SIX CHANGES MADE

agilia

BACK

MENU

SP

MC

STOP

ON/OFF

START

BOLUS

OK

1. Calibration error

2. Rate entry

3. IV set visuals

4. Start and Stop

5. Screen display

6. Syringe keypad

Volumetric infusion pump

Syringe infusion pump

B. Braun Infusomat Compact Plus

Fresenius Kabi Agilia SP MC

Fingers press IV tubing, squeezing fluid like a wave. Holds IV bag for fluids, antibiotics and blood products. Designed for large volumes.

A motor drives a screw that pushes the syringe plunger at a slow speed. Holds 10, 20, or 50 mL syringes for small volumes.

Anatomy of the infusion pumps and accessories

Only the parts that need explaining, or that carry a design finding, are labelled.

BOLUS

Button for giving medication with faster rate

Directional Keys + OK

Volumetric infusion pump with the IV line cavity open

Display

Green Clamp Seat

Pumping Cavity

IV line goes here

Volumetric infusion pump with the IV line going through the cavity

IV Bag

Contains Medication

IV Line

Goes inside pumping cavity

Roller Clamp

Manual medication Flow Control, Open before starting

Door (Pumping Cavity)

OK/START Button

Syringe Infusion pump

Alarm Silence Button

Digit after decimal

Whole Digit

BOLUS

Syringe Clamp

Button for giving medication with faster rate

Syringe Cavity

Syringe goes here

Understanding Mental Models

A mental model is the nurse’s view of how an infusion pump works, shaped by experience, peer actions and

training. It influences their screen reading, expectations and setup actions for a critically ill child.

Where that picture and the pump’s real interface disagree is

where hesitation, errors and stress build up. Designing

around those gaps, with clearer prompts, better feedback and controls that behave the way nurses expect, makes set- up smoother and safer.

01

02

03

04

05

Observe

Score

Model

Review

Interview

4 set-ups

DISCO, 0 to 5

Mental model mapper

Gestalt audit

5 people

Four participants set up a pump. Two sessions had a patient present.

Error and stress rated 0–5 at every step against a written rubric.

What each person expects the pump to do before they touch it.

Each front panel checked against Gestalt and visual design principles.

Five people, from the paediatrician to the biomedical engineer.

ON SITE at Manipal Hospital, Yelahanka

Our site visits to the PICU, where we observed nurses setting up pumps and spoke with the staff who use them.

Click here to read field notes

Read the field notes

Infusion Pump Users

Four people set up a pump in front of us. Each one brings a mental model, the picture of the pump they carry in their head. It decides what they expect each screen and button to do and where they hesitate.

PAEDIATRIC ICU

PAEDIATRIC ICU

INFUSION PUMP STUDY · PARTICIPANT

INFUSION PUMP STUDY · PARTICIPANT

Hema

Nargis

Intern Nurse

Physician Assistant

Experience

Experience

What they said

What they said

13 years · BSc Nursing

6 months · BSc Nursing

Setting

Setting

“A device to be dealt with carefully.”

“I look through everything thoroughly and make sure it all runs smoothly.”

Paediatric ICU, patient present

Paediatric ICU, no patient present

Pump studied

Pump studied

Motivation

Learns by

Volumetric Pump (VIP)

Volumetric Pump (VIP)

Language

Language

Motivation

Learns by

Wants to complete the infusion correctly, under the guidance of her seniors.

Watching her peers and doing the work as her seniors in the ward direct.

Comfortable in English, Hindi

Comfortable in Hindi

Keeps everyone cross- checked, takes on work beyond her role and wants to get home to her kids.

13 years on the ward. Builds her own workarounds when a machine gets in the way.

PICU · VIP · HEMA

PICU · VIP · NARGIS

PAEDIATRIC ICU

PAEDIATRIC ICU

INFUSION PUMP STUDY · PARTICIPANT

INFUSION PUMP STUDY · PARTICIPANT

Mariya

Deswin

Nurse

Biomedical Engineer

Experience

Experience

What they said

What they said

4 years · BSc Nursing

2 years

Setting

Setting

“These patients are very time-sensitive and I have to deal with many of them at once.”

“I’m always a call away. If there’s an issue, people usually call me.”

Paediatric ICU, patient present

Paediatric ICU, no patient present

Pump studied

Pump studied

Syringe Pump (SIP)

Both pumps (VIP, SIP)

Language

Language

Motivation

Learns by

Motivation

Learns by

Comfortable in English, Hindi

Comfortable in English

Wants to do her best work and finish every infusion on time, across 3 to 4 beds and up to 6 pumps.

Asking for help when she needs it. Worked at a private clinic before this ward.

One call away. Briefs staff on new machines and fixes whatever goes wrong with them.

Training passed down to him, not the manuals. Asks his superiors when unsure.

PICU · VIP + SIP · DESWIN

PICU · SIP · MARIYA

What we saw across the four

Three of the four slipped at the same few steps.

Nargis and Deswin both typed a wrong value first when entering the rate. Hema picked the wrong infusion line. When the intern and the engineer who trains everyone slip at the same step, the problem sits in the interface.

Ecosystem around Infusion Pumps

The pump is the final step in a chain of handoffs, where information can be misread or delayed.

Doctor

consults the patient and writes the prescription in the system.

Shift manager

the order and delegates it to nurses and physician assistants.

present

2in ICU 2

Physician Assistant

checks, organises & supervises nurses and interns

Infusion Pump

present in ICU 2

2

Nurses

transcribe the prescription to the Drug Card and bed chart, prepare and dilute the drug & operate the pump.

present in ICU 2

7

Interns

assist and monitor under supervision.

present in ICU 2

3

Biomedical Engineer

troubleshoot any machine or software issue.

present on demand at all times

1

User Journey Map

Two set-ups, step by step, as we watched them. Red steps are where the pump and the user’s mental model disagreed. The rail on the right says what we saw at each one.

Syringe pump, observed with Mariya (nurse), patient present

Where it breaks

Illustrated

Illustrated

Step 1, Read the order

Rushing, keeping other patients in mind at the same time. She keeps a drug card by each bed and works from them.

DRUG

DOSE

PATIENT

Step 3, Prepare the medication

The mix is done from memory. The only check is the marks on the barrel.

Step 1

Read the order

Step 2

Collect equipment

Step 3

Prepare the medication

Step 6, Program the infusion

The number goes from paper to machine only through her head. She watches the key, not the number.

Step 7, Start and verify

Step 4

Load the syringe

Step 5

Power on, confirm syringe

Step 6

Program the infusion

She turns the rate like a dial until the time looks right.

Step 8, Monitor

2

1

She carries this patient’s case in her head while working at other beds.

3

What Mariya told us

1

2

3

SITE

ALARM

RESTART

She runs between three or four beds and can’t keep track of everything. When the mL written on the card and the timing given differ, she goes with time over volume.

Step 7

Start and verify

Step 8

Monitor the infusion

Volumetric pump, observed with Hema (physician assistant), patient present

Where it breaks

Select infusion line

Paused, looked at both options and picked the wrong line. No feedback for the wrong choice.

Line calibration error

A pink error screen. Its only button silences the alarm and the instruction together.

Step 2

Insert IV line in cavity

Step 3

Press clamp into place

Step 1

Close roller clamp

Recovery loop

It takes five steps to get back. Open the latch, check for kinks, reposition, close and select the line again.

Selection of IV set type: No feedback for the wrong choice

Rate and volume

Digits fill right to left, against the way she reads a number.

What Hema told us

She keeps everything organised and in line and cross-checks other people’s work. She believes in work-life balance. She has kids at home and wants to get back to them.

Step 4

Position IV line again

Step 6

Select infusion line

Step 5

Close the door & latch

Vague Alarm and gets removed entirely in one button

Step 7

Line calibration error

Step 8

Open latch to check

Step 9

Check for kinks in line

Step 11

Close door

Step 12

Set infusion line again

Step 10

Position line again

Input Rate and mental model mismatch: Input right to left

Input Rate and mental model mismatch: Input right to left

Step 13

Input infusion rate

Step 15

Start infusion

Step 14

Input total volume

In their words

What the PICU staff told us about their work. The first row is paraphrased from our conversations. The second row is in their own words.

What they told us, paraphrased

Hema, physician assistant

Mariya, nurse

Deswin, biomedical engineer

Paediatrician

She keeps everyone in line and cross-checks their work. She takes on work beyond her role to prove herself and still wants to get home to her kids on time.

She rushes between three or four beds and goes by the clock more than the mL. She keeps a drug card by each bed and works from them.

He decides what each patient needs and puts it in the system. The nurses and in-charges coordinate from there. He sees a patient himself when a check-up is needed and hands extra tasks to staff who ask for more. Overall he oversees the ward and the patients who need a consultation.

Always one call away. When a pump misbehaves, they call him. He briefs staff on new machines and learnt the pumps from someone else’s training, not the manual.

What they said

“I am working morning and night shifts alternatively, always alert on call.”

“I picked it up from my first briefing. Within a day or two I knew the pump and was confident using it.”

“I have to always stay on my toes, navigating between multiple patients in a day.”

“I am always a call away.”

Deswin, biomedical engineer

Hema, physician assistant

Mariya, nurse

Nargis, intern nurse

A workaround on the ward, syringe pump

When the last mL won’t push, Hema wedges a cap between the back of the syringe and the pump’s jaws.

She does the same to make syringes fit that otherwise wouldn’t. Deswin mentioned that this was a problem in the system and that it had to be worked around. For the staff on the floor the infusion has to get done. A workaround is a sign the interface has failed the person using it.

Observed on the floor

3 systems, 1 whiteboard and 3 logbooks are in use on the floor at all times.

Synthesis of problem areas

Volumetric

Analysing problem areas and design opportunities.

Syringe

Design opportunities

1. Calibration error

2. Rate and volume entry

3. IV set selection

Several possible causes for the alarm and no clear steps to fix it.

Digits fill right to left, so units and decimals get missed in a rush.

Picking the IV set by name is easy to get wrong. The choice on screen should match the set in hand.

4. Start and Stop placement

5. Display priorities

6. Button icons and layout

Two opposite actions share a small surface, so the wrong one gets pressed.

The rate fills the screen while time left and volume stay small, though staff read pumps from across the room.

No clear OK key. Look-alike icons hide what each button does.

Design Approach

Nurses know these pumps. Changes include control placement, names and screen messages.

Volumetric pump

Syringe pump

agilia

BACK

MENU

SP

MC

ON/OFF

STOP

START

BOLUS

OK

ORIGINAL

REDESIGNED

ORIGINAL

REDESIGNED

B. Braun Infusomat Compact Plus

Fresenius Kabi Agilia SP MC

Try the redesigned pump

The volumetric redesign, built in HTML to run in the browser.

Click here to see prototype

Prototype built in Claude Design

REDESIGNED VOLUMETRIC PUMP

Redesigning the screens and buttons

Each change keeps the familiar shape and fixes the logic underneath.

We redesigned the controls we could build into a working simulation first. The rest is listed under future scope.

Volumetric pump

1

No way forward after the line calibration error

BEFORE

THE PROBLEM

A warning reads “Line Calibration Error. Close roller clamp and check infusion line.” Its only button, “Confirm Alarm”, silences the beep and the instruction. Nurses tap it, move on and get stuck again.

THE CHANGE

Four checks. The alarm is silenced in the first step so the nurse can focus on the checklist.

AFTER

4: “Line calibrated”, go to rate

1: Silence the alarm, keep the error

2: Check clamp and air bubbles

3: Check line position and door

WHY IT WORKS

The error stays visible until it is fixed and each check is shown, not described.

Seen in Hema’s volumetric journey, steps 7 to 12

Volumetric pump

2

Rate and volume entry against the mental model

BEFORE

THE PROBLEM

The pump fills digits right to left. To enter 80 mL/h, the nurse sets the units digit (0) first, then the tens digit (8). Sometimes the wrong value goes in and has to be corrected.

THE CHANGE

The cursor starts in the first box and types left to right. A separate key adds the decimal point.

AFTER

Cursor starts on the first box, reading “0 mL/h”.

Each digit can be set with the directional arrows before a decimal point.

The decimal point has a button of its own near the other keys.

WHY IT WORKS

Input order matches reading order and the read-back catches a wrong value before OK.

Seen with Nargis and Deswin, who typed a wrong value first; volumetric journey, steps 13 and 14

Volumetric pump

3

Selecting the IV set by name

BEFORE

AFTER

“Select Infusion Line” shows Intrafix Primeline and SafeSet. Both start the same and a default set is highlighted. Nurses often accept the highlighted row without checking.

Use picture cards instead of text. Each card shows an

illustration and name, positioned to align with left and right keys.

WHY IT WORKS

The picture matches the IV set in hand.

Seen in Hema’s volumetric journey, step 6

Volumetric pump

4

Start and Stop sit too close

BEFORE

AFTER

Start and Stop share a split button, red on top and green

Start and Stop become two separate physical keys. Stop

below. Two actions sit close together, making it easy for a hurried nurse to press the wrong half.

is red, the largest key and the easiest to reach. Start is green.

WHY IT WORKS

Start is where the programmed dose reaches the child, so it takes a deliberate press at the end of set-up. Stop is larger and red, so it is easy to find under stress.

Seen in the Gestalt review of the volumetric front panel

Volumetric pump

5

Display screen priorities

BEFORE

AFTER

The rate fills the screen. VTBI and time are small. Nurses check pumps from afar, often asking, “how long until this runs out?”

Rate first, time left second, then infused and VTBI below. The unit is readable and tagged for quick reference.

WHY IT WORKS

Built for a nurse watching up to six pumps across three or four beds. Rate stays on top and time left moves up from the bottom to second, because that is what staff check from across the room.

Seen in Mariya’s syringe journey, steps 7 and 8

Syringe pump

6

Syringe display and button layout

BEFORE

AFTER

agilia

BACK

MENU

SP

MC

ON/OFF

STOP

START

BOLUS

OK

LOOK-ALIKE KEYS

LOOK-ALIKE KEYS

ON/OFF, Bolus, Menu, Back look alike.

Grouped by role: navigation, confirm, action.

HIGH-RISK ACTION

HIGH-RISK ACTION

Bolus is not set apart from routine keys.

Bolus is amber, Stop red, Start green, each a distinct shape.

ARROWS

ARROWS

Arrows conflict with natural left and right.

Arrows follow the numeral system.

CONFIRM AND BACK

CONFIRM AND BACK

No dedicated OK. The circular back arrow reads as refresh or cancel.

Explicit OK and Back labels replace ambiguous symbols.

WHY IT WORKS

Recognition over recall and risk differentiation on the high-consequence keys.

Seen in the Gestalt review of the syringe front panel; Mariya’s syringe journey, step 6

Key Takeaways

High risk sits off-screen

Memory over checks

Drug dilution is the riskiest step, yet the pump gives no help.

Values are entered from memory, which skips safe verification.

Future scope, yet to explore

What we saw on the ward but have not designed for yet.

Drug labelling

Drug card position

Cables across the patient

Start and Stop across devices

Medicines are labelled by hand on stickers stuck to IV bags and syringes.

The drug card has no fixed place near the patient’s bed.

The pump and the monitor sit on opposite sides, so cables cross the child and block the view of the vitals.

We are working out how Start and Stop should sit across the different pumps on the ward, so habits carry over safely under stress.

The last 2 mL

Unused settings

Possible dosage issue

The syringe pump stops before the syringe is empty, so staff wedge a cap in to push the rest.

Settings on the device that the nurses do not know exist.

A dosage reading in the software that may be off and needs checking with the biomedical team.

What’s next

We are now testing the redesign with the PICU nurses and collecting their feedback. Early responses say the buttons make sense, so we are looking into it further. Running it in a simulation would show us what still needs work.